
I know this movie has been out for a while but I just got around to seeing it yesterday and had to pitch in my two cents. The movie was highly recommended by a good friend of mine who is a big-time movie buff so I went in this expecting it to be a pretty big deal… but it didn’t quite deliver.
First off, I do think it was cool that Clint Eastwood tried to develop a movie around the conflicts in a Hmong community. It’s a pretty bold move for Eastwood to lend his star power to shed light on Hmong gang violence. But aside from the A for effort, the movie was pretty much a bust in my opinion. Would it really kill Hollywood to tell a story where a Hmong person was the one to resolve the conflict? Instead we get a snarling, macho, white guy (Walt Kowalski/Eastwood) who saves the Hmong women and children from their own kind. Likewise, it irked me that a huge part of the plot was about Eastwood teaching Thao, the teenage Hmong boy, what it means to be a man. According to the movie, a real man drowns his conversations in a stream of curses, totes a big gun, and works in construction. I know that Eastwood is supposed to play a very grumpy and abrasive character but it’s so overdone. Likewise, the interactions between Walt and Thao/his sister Sue (played by Bee Vang and Ahney Her) were awkward and unnatural. Even after they become friends and Walt comes over to have a barbecue at their house, he continues to call them gooks and somehow it’s supposed to be endearing… yeah, that doesn’t usually do it for me. Although it’s always good to have more Asian faces on the big screen, I’m still going to be critical of their acting abilities. True, they weren’t working with the best script but Vang and Her’s performances, to be honest, weren’t all that hot. But hey, if nothing else, at least this movie has helped a few more people pronounce Hmong correctly (that silent “h” is a trickster).
Agree or disagree? Leave me a comment and let me know :)


